Our Fault Explained: The Twists, Secrets, and High-Stakes Drama Everyone’s Talking About

Prime Video is closing out its wildly messy, can-not-look-away Culpable saga with the third film, Our Fault. If you have opinions about Noah and Nick (and who doesn’t at this point), here’s where the last chapter is headed and what Nicole Wallace is saying about it.

What Our Fault is actually about

Set almost a year after Noah Morgan (Nicole Wallace) and Nick Leister’s brutal breakup, fate shoves them back into each other’s orbit. Shocking no one: old wounds rip open, jealousy spikes, tempers flare, and those unresolved feelings refuse to stay buried. The tease that should make fans perk up: a life-changing discovery drops in the middle of all that noise, forcing both of them to reassess what they want and whether the other person is still part of it.

The expectation from fans is pretty clear: redemption and an actual happy ending this time. We’ll see if the movie sticks the landing.

Quick status check: the trilogy so far

• My Fault (dir. Domingo González) - released June 8, 2023 - Rotten Tomatoes critic score: 0%
• Your Fault (dir. Domingo González) - released December 18, 2024 - Rotten Tomatoes critic score: 18%
• Our Fault (dir. Domingo González) - premieres October 16, 2025 - Rotten Tomatoes: not yet rated

Yes, those critic scores are rough. And yes, the audience for these movies is still very much locked in. Inside baseball note: it’s rare for a franchise to get pummeled by critics and still build this kind of anticipation for the finale.

Nicole Wallace on Noah: strength, honesty, and actually feeling stuff

Wallace has lived with Noah across two films now, and she’s not shy about what makes the character tick. In a 2024 chat with Collider, she zeroed in on Noah’s directness and emotional honesty — the kind of traits that are great on screen and slightly terrifying in real life.

"She’s a very strong character. She’s a very strong woman... I love so many things about her. Just being able to express every feeling that she has so directly and without second guessing is very beautiful and is something that sometimes I don’t do as well. Being able to do it through her has been very fulfilling."

She also pointed out that the real power in Noah isn’t the tough exterior — it’s the vulnerability underneath. After more than two years with the role, Wallace described it like watching a friend weather a breakup and grow through it. She’s back as Noah for the trilogy capper, which adapts Mercedes Ron’s bestselling Culpables books (the movies are the Prime Video spin on that series).

So... do Noah and Nick finally settle down?

The studio’s tease strongly hints at closure: forgiveness, stability, maybe even a future that doesn’t implode every five minutes. If you’re crossing your fingers for a full-on happy ending, you’re not reading the tea leaves wrong.

Wallace has her eye on Charlie’s Angels next

After making her feature debut with My Fault and riding the sequel, Wallace told Collider she’s ready to go full action trio. Her words: "Yeah, it’s crazy. It was my first film, ever. It’s not something that happens all the time." On planes during promo, she kept rewatching Charlie’s Angels and decided she’d love to suit up for a reboot — "They’re so cool and so bada**."

A quick refresher: the early 2000s Charlie’s Angels films starred Cameron Diaz, Drew Barrymore, and Lucy Liu as undercover operatives for the never-seen boss, Charlie. The 2019 reboot, written and directed by Elizabeth Banks and starring Kristen Stewart, Naomi Scott, and Ella Balinska, didn’t hit as planned — mixed reviews and $73 million worldwide on a $48 million budget, per Box Office Mojo. If someone does take another swing, Wallace clearly wants in.

What she’s doing in the meantime

Wallace is set for Prime Video’s The House of Spirits, adapted from Isabel Allende’s debut novel and produced by Eva Longoria. Different lane, big pedigree.

Release details

Our Fault premieres on Prime Video on October 16, 2025.

My Fault (2023) and Your Fault (2024) are streaming now on Prime Video if you want to relive the chaos before the finale.