All’s Fair Season 2: Plot Teases, Cast Comebacks, and Renewal Odds You Need to Know

If you finished All's Fair season 1 and immediately needed to lay down, same. Hulu already hit the renew button, and season 2 is coming, which is good because that finale basically tossed a courtroom grenade into every relationship on the board.

Spoilers ahead for the All's Fair season 1 finale.

Quick reset: how season 1 left everyone in shambles

Liberty bailed on her wedding after discovering Reggie had quietly stacked up debt. Carrington did what Carrington does: engineered chaos at the firm, made Dina look unhinged, and set events in motion that ended with Dina arrested for murdering Emerald's rapist. Allura and Chase? Wreckage there too, after Carrington wedged herself into their mess. And now we wait to see who can crawl out from under it.

Yes, season 2 is officially happening

All's Fair premiered on Hulu on November 4, 2025, and it did not exactly tiptoe in. It was loud, glossy, and proudly over-the-top. Variety summed up the vibe with this:

Variety called it a "camp classic".

Hulu renewed the series in November, so we are guaranteed at least one more round of legal lunacy, relationship warfare, and extremely pointed office glassware.

Who is back for season 2

• Kim Kardashian as Allura Grant: Expect Allura ready to go toe-to-toe with Carrington. Kardashian has been teasing more to come on Instagram.
• Naomi Watts as Liberty Ronson: That blown-up wedding and Reggie's money secrets are not done with her.
• Niecy Nash-Betts as Emerald Greene: Her personal fallout is tangled up with Dina's arrest, and Nash-Betts has hinted at her return on Instagram.
• Teyana Taylor as Milan: Pregnant with Chase's child, which keeps her smack in the middle of the Allura/Carrington/Chase triangle.
• Matthew Noszka as Chase: The man at the center of multiple disasters is not going anywhere.
• Sarah Paulson as Carrington Lane: Her manipulation streak is now baked into the firm's power structure.
• Glenn Close as Dina Standish: Arrested, embattled, and suddenly the axis of the show's legal and moral questions.
• Probably out: Ed O'Neill as Doug Standish, who died at the end of season 1 — unless we get flashbacks or dream detours.

Season 2: what I expect the show to do with all this

Dina's arrest is the big engine. Carrington maneuvered the optics just enough to paint Dina as unstable, and now we're staring down a murder case with real stakes for everyone at the firm. Expect courtroom fireworks and a lot of uncomfortable lines about justice, loyalty, and who is using whom.

Allura and Chase are on a collision course. Carrington's meddling blew up whatever trust was left, and Milan's pregnancy with Chase's baby adds a very real, very permanent complication. A clean reconciliation seems unlikely, but for this show, sparks can fly even when peace will not.

Liberty and Reggie feel unfinished, and not just because the wedding imploded. If he stops hiding and actually owns the debt situation, there is a path to something resembling redemption. Messy, sure. Impossible, no.

Case-of-the-week chaos is still part of the DNA here — blink-and-you-missed-it resolutions, celebrity cameos, and divorces that make zero real-world sense but are undeniably watchable. The Walton murder case is positioned to be a season-long anchor, though, so expect the show to balance its quick-hit satire with a more sustained legal battle.

The vibe going forward

Season 2 looks primed to lean into rivalries and power plays: Carrington climbing, Allura pushing back, Emerald fighting through the fallout, Liberty trying to rebuild, and Dina battling both the system and the narrative Carrington stuck her with. If season 1 was the spark, season 2 is the accelerant.

All's Fair is streaming exclusively on Hulu.