Forget the Missing Arm: The Real Reason Mihawk Wouldn't Fight Shanks — And Why That One Piece Theory Falls Apart

One Piece loves a good mystery, and few relationships are as tantalizingly under-explained as Shanks vs. Dracule Mihawk. Fans have begged for a proper answer to why those two stopped crossing swords. The usual explanation is straightforward. A new fan theory takes it somewhere much stranger.

The accepted reason they stopped

The common read is: Mihawk walked away because dueling a one-armed Shanks would be dishonorable.

Clean, simple, and it fits Mihawk’s code. But that’s not the only angle floating around.

The GrandLineReview twist: what if that wasn’t Shanks?

GrandLineReview on YouTube pitched a theory that reframes the whole rivalry: Mihawk didn’t quit because Shanks lost an arm. He quit because, post-arm-loss, the man in front of him didn’t feel like the same opponent. The idea goes that Mihawk sensed a different presence entirely — meaning the Shanks he met later wasn’t actually Shanks.

Here’s where it veers into deep-cut fan territory. The theory leans on the notion that Shanks has a twin named Shamrock who steps in at specific moments in history. In that read, Mihawk realized he was facing the stand-in, not the guy he’d spent years measuring himself against, and he tapped out of the rivalry.

How the twin angle tries to solve the timeline weirdness

The theory isn’t just vibes; it tries to solve a real head-scratcher from Marineford era continuity. Fans have long wondered how Shanks could clash with Kaido in the New World and then pop up to halt the Marineford war basically immediately after. Before Shamrock became a popular name in theory circles, people were already using a twin concept to explain that logistical magic trick. Split the duties: one handles Kaido, the other walks into Marineford with perfect timing. Easy, if you buy the premise.

• What the theory says: Mihawk sensed that post-arm-loss Shanks wasn’t the same person he used to duel, so he ended the rivalry on principle.
• The twin piece: a supposed twin, Shamrock, occasionally replaces Shanks during key events, which could explain why someone as perceptive as Mihawk felt the difference.
• The timeline hook: one Shanks handles Kaido in the New World; the other appears at Marineford to stop the war. That neat split covers the near-instant travel problem.
• Why Mihawk, specifically: as the world’s top swordsman, he’d notice if his favorite sparring partner suddenly had a different presence, rhythm, or energy.
• The big counterpoints: at Marineford, Shanks chats with Buggy like the childhood friends they are. A twin would have to know their shared history flawlessly to pull that off. Also, the Red Hair Pirates show zero signs of running with two captains.
• Where it ties into broader Shanks mysteries: recent flashback material and reader conversations keep adding layers — his time with the Roger Pirates, possible ties to the Celestial Dragons, and that brief, eyebrow-raising appearance in Mariejois. Some fans link him (or people connected to him) to the group often nicknamed the devoted blades of God, which only muddies the waters further.

Shanks lore keeps getting bigger (and messier)

Shanks has been central since chapter one, yet Oda has kept him behind multiple curtains. The ongoing endgame push has teased more of his past with the Roger Pirates and stirred up talk of bloodlines and power structures most pirates never touch. Toss in his quiet drop-in at Mariejois during the Reverie and all those Celestial Dragon whispers, and the character only gets more enigmatic.

In other words: the longer Oda hides the ball, the wilder the theories get. The hope is that, with the Final Saga underway, we finally get concrete answers that connect Shanks to the larger endgame instead of just adding new question marks.

So, did Mihawk know a secret?

As a story pitch, the twin idea is fun precisely because it explains the Marineford timing and gives Mihawk a clean, character-driven reason to bow out. But the Buggy conversation and the very normal way the Red Hair Pirates operate are tough hurdles. File it under: spicy, clever, and unproven.

What do you think — are Shanks’ impending revelations setting up one of the series’ biggest rug-pulls, or are we overthinking a simple code-of-honor moment?

One Piece is streaming on Crunchyroll.