Fans Demand Marvel Delete Tobey Maguire’s Gut-Punch Death Scene in Avengers: Doomsday
Rumors are swirling that Tobey Maguire will swing back into Avengers: Doomsday — and it could be his final bow, with insider buzz hinting the veteran Spider-Man meets a shocking fate in the film’s opening moments.
So, the Spider-Man rumor mill is raging again, and this time it is all about Tobey Maguire possibly swinging back in for Avengers: Doomsday... and maybe swinging out for good. Yes, the same Tobey whose Spidey basically built the modern superhero blockbuster. The latest chatter: he shows up, and it might be the last time he puts on the suit. Some fans are even bracing for something way harsher than a graceful exit.
Why everyone is suddenly worried about Tobey
- Recent insider buzz says Tobey Maguire is part of Avengers: Doomsday.
- A newer rumor claims this could be his final Spider-Man appearance.
- The spiciest theory: Tobey's Spider-Man dies in the opening minutes. As in, cold open gut-punch.
- That idea set off a wave of reactions, including a viral post from Matt Ramos (aka @therealsupes) on November 16, 2025. Ramos is an actor (At Midnight) and a credited producer on the podcast The Let's Go With the Supes.
- Fuel on the fire: on September 7, 2025, a fan named @Curtis1192 shared a selfie with Tobey in London. The post blew up because...
- ...London is where Avengers: Doomsday is shooting right now. It is also where Spider-Man: Brand New Day is filming. The obvious conclusion: Tobey is there for one of those, and most fans are betting it is Doomsday.
- Fan theories go further: picture the movie starting with Tobey's Peter witnessing a multiversal fracture and the entrance of Doom. Big, dramatic, messy. None of that is confirmed, but you can see why the speculation is sticky.
'Marvel Studios, I love you guys but in the case that y'all kill Tobey in Avengers Doomsday... delete that scene, destroy the footage files & never talk about it ever.'
Is Marvel really going to open a mega-event movie by taking out Tobey? Wild idea. If true, that scene would absolutely nuke the internet. If not, this is still a fascinating peek at where fan expectations are right now.
Should Marvel retire him or wreck us?
Tobey kicked off his Peter Parker run in 2002 and helped define what superhero movies became. People love this version because he is the blueprint. With Marvel shifting into new phases, there is a logical argument for giving him a proper exit. Let him pass the torch, not die to motivate somebody else. Think more Captain America-style retirement than tragic sendoff.
There are also ongoing reports that Tom Holland may eventually step away from the role down the line, which only strengthens the case for dignified handoffs instead of body counts. The multiverse gives Marvel endless ways to honor these characters without closing the door with a funeral.
Where this stands right now
None of this is officially confirmed. The Tobey-in-London sighting is real, the productions in London line up, and the theories are... enthusiastic. Until Marvel speaks, file it under credible-but-unverified rumor territory.
Key date to circle
Avengers: Doomsday hits theaters on December 18, 2026 in the US.
Do you think Marvel would really kill Tobey's Spider-Man in the opening? Or is this just the fandom scaring itself for sport?