All Her Fault Season 2: Is the Show Coming Back or Gone for Good?

Peacock wrapped All Her Fault with a clean answer to the big mystery, but it left a couple character threads dangling just enough to make fans wonder: is this a one-and-done or are we coming back for seconds?

Where things stand

Short version: Peacock has not renewed All Her Fault for Season 2. That silence is not shocking. The show was built as a limited thriller led by Sarah Snook and based on Andrea Mara's standalone novel. The finale closes the central kidnapping plot, and the whole thing was marketed as a self-contained story. So a straight-up Season 2 continuation is, frankly, a long shot.

That said, nobody at Peacock has slammed the door shut. Streamers typically wait weeks, sometimes months, to see how a show performs before they make the call. If All Her Fault pops in viewership and keeps people subscribed, a renewal is not impossible.

If it returns, it probably won’t look like Season 1

Given how decisively the main mystery was resolved, the more realistic path would be an anthology-style follow-up. That could mean new arcs built around Marissa Irvine (Sarah Snook) or Jenny (Dakota Fanning) on separate tracks, rather than trying to stretch the same case past its natural endpoint. If Peacock wants more of this world, that pivot would make the most sense.

• Status: No renewal announced; not officially canceled either.
• Source material: Andrea Mara's novel is a standalone, which lowers the odds of a direct Season 2.
• Story state: The kidnapping plot is resolved; a traditional continuation would be tough to justify.
• Timing reality: Streamers often wait a while to analyze performance before deciding.
• Possible approach: An anthology-style second installment focused on Marissa and/or Jenny with new arcs.

Bottom line: Season 2 is neither confirmed nor off the table. It all comes down to Peacock running the numbers. For now, consider All Her Fault a complete story with the tiniest window open for a reimagined return.